Our Team

Each licensed insurance agent in our office is ready to put their years of experience to work finding you the ideal option for your insurance needs.

Lori Caldwell

Insurance Agent, CIC

Lori (Dwyer) Caldwell graduated from McAuley High School in 1983 and began her college education at the Florida Institute of Technology. Her schooling continued as she traveled with her family

Daniel T. Dwyer, Jr.

Insurance Agent, AAI, CIC

Dan Dwyer Jr. has been in the insurance business since 1991 when he joined the agency after duty in the armed forces during Desert Shield and Desert Storm. He is

Marty J. Dwyer

Insurance Agent

Marty joined the agency part time shortly after graduating from LaSalle High School in 1997, then full-time after attending The University of Cincinnati Marty started by learning the ropes of

Tanya Macke

Insurance Agent

Tanya graduated from McAuley High School in 1995. She joined Dwyer Insurance in 2003 and gained her property and casualty agent’s license in 2005. Since joining the agency Tanya continues

Katie Wickman

Insurance Agent

Katie attended both McAuley and Colerain High Schools and graduated in 1994. After working several years with her father’s consulting business she moved on to work 12 years with the

Deanne Poli

Insurance Agent

Deanne Poli joined the agency in January 2010 after working for another local agency. She graduated from McAuley H.S. in 1988, obtained a B.S. from the University of Cincinnati in

M. Scott Stewart

Insurance Agent

Scott began his insurance career in 1991; when he joined his father in their family agency. He graduated from Boone County High School in 1989 and obtained his degree from

Brett Schwiebert

Insurance Agent

Brett is a 2012 graduate of Patrick Henry High School in Hamler, Ohio. He then attended the University of Cincinnati where he became a manager for the women’s basketball program

Sarah Johnson

Insurance Agent

Sarah is a recent Oak Hills High School graduate. After completing high school in 2017, she started working at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center. There, she found her passion for

Joshua C. Willis

Insurance Agent

Josh attended Chicago State University where he majored in psychology and played Division I baseball before working for the Chicago Tribune. Later, he moved to Cincinnati and worked as a

Brady Renners

Insurance Agent

Brady Renners recently joined the Dwyer Insurance Agency. He has extensive insurance experience from owning and operating Brady Renners & Associates Insurance Agency for 28 years. Brady is a 1989

Jill Young

Insurance Agent

Jill graduated from William Henry Harrison High School and continued her education by getting her BS from Trine University while playing soccer and basketball. She worked for 23 years at

Samantha Lanter

Administrative Assistant

Samantha graduated from Colerain High School in 2015. She has a background in the medical field, where she honored her customer service skills and discovered her passion for helping others.

Olivia Hawkins

Administrative Assistant

Olivia is a graduate of Roger Bacon High School (2019). She went on to attend the University of Cincinnati, where she earned a bachelor's degree in Business Administration. She has

Daniel T. Dwyer, Sr.

CIC – Our Founder

Dan Dwyer Sr. has been in the insurance business since he graduated from St. Xavier High School in 1960. Starting in the mailroom at Maryland Casualty Company, he continued working